Nutella-Stuffed Challah French Toast

The key to good french toast is day-old challah.

IMG 7937

Sometimes more than a day old.

In fact, the more stale the bread, the better it will hold up as french toast.

IMG 7945

I mean, don’t get me wrong – you don’t want it so stale that it’s crumbling in your hands…but it should be a little less than springy to the touch when you go to make the french toast.

IMG 7954

And then, if you really want to get crazy, split each slice open and lather it with nutella…

IMG 7985

IMG 7968

IMG 7969

Just try and tell me breakfast gets better than this.  I’m pretty sure you won’t be able to say it with a straight face.

And if you do, I may or may not blow on you to make you blink.  Because the truth is, breakfast doesn’t get better than this (until the next thing I make that I think is delicious.  but shh – no one needs to know that right now).

Okay sorry, back to the point.

Once you’ve assembled your “sandwich” then it’s time to create the egg mixture…

IMG 8001

All you need is eggs, milk (or heavy cream if you’re really feeling decadent), vanilla and cinnamon.

IMG 8010

Generously dip the entire “sandwich” into the egg mixture making sure to allow each side to soak for at least one minute.

Transfer the egg soaked sandwich to a greased pan over medium-high heat (be careful not to turn the heat up too high or the french toast will burn).

Cook 3-5 minutes each side (or until lightly browned)…and viola!

IMG 8038

Top with powdered sugar…

IMG 8041Screen shot 2012 05 06 at 1 53 30 PMIMG 8047

Then with maple syrup…

IMG 8059

IMG 8062

And enjoy!
IMG 8063

Nutella-Stuffed French Toast {for two}


  • 1 day-old loaf of challah bread
  • 2 eggs (1 per person, so if you’re making this for two, 2 eggs will suffice.  4 for four people, etc.)
  • 1/2 tsp. vanilla
  • 1/4 cup milk (or heavy cream)
  • 1/2 tsp. cinnamon
  • 4 tbsp. Nutella (or chocolate hazelnut spread of choice)
  • Powdered sugar (optional)
  • Maple syrup (optional)


  1. Slice challah bread into 2 inch slices, then slice each 2-inch slice in half
  2. Spread one side of the halved bread slice with 2 tbsp. nutella and top with other half, set aside
  3. In a large pan or bowl, mix together eggs, vanilla, milk and cinnamon, stirring to combine
  4. Drop the sandwich into the egg mixture allowing each side to soak in the mixture for at least one minute
  5. Place the egg soaked sandwich on a greased pan over medium heat, cooking about 3-5 minutes each side or until lightly browned
  6. Allow sandwich to cool 5 minutes then top with powdered sugar and maple syrup.

IMG 8065

  • chelcie @ chelcie’s food files

    umm i’m DROOLING

  • Liz @ Tip Top Shape

    This looks amazing! I don’t think I’ve ever tried challah bread before.

    • Cait

      Oh my gosh – you HAVE to try it for french toast…there is literally nothing better!

  • Margarita

    Wow! I want these… But there’s no challah bread around, so I will have to settle for something else. I would totally make this for dessert, with strawberries on the side. Or a scoop of ice cream.

    • Cait

      Oooh I like where your head is at! :)

  • MigraineMe

    Looks delicious! I have heard of this before, but never tried it!

  • Sarena (The Non-Dairy Queen)

    I think I need to put in a little extra workout just looking at these pictures! So decadent!

    • Cait

      Haha totally – but it’s COMPLETELY worth it ;)

  • Jenn

    OMG Cait, that looks SO good! Let me know when you’re in Boston next and feel like cooking up something for a starving college student ;)

    • Cait

      Hahaha – I definitely will! :)

  • Sheila

    This looks wonderful!! OHH the calories, but looks so worth the extra workout!

  • Jenny

    Oh my goodness. Amazing idea. I love it!

    • Cait

      Thanks Jenny! :)

  • Val @ Tips on Healthy Living

    Gorgeous! Nutella is such a classic. I’d maybe add some thin-sliced bananas. feel like there are endless combinations your could do here… like the Trader Joe’s Cookie butter in the middle drizzled with melted dark chocolate… or mascarpone and strawberries in the middle… MMM

    • Cait

      I actually thought about the strawberries…definitely need to do that next time!

  • Hayley @ Oat Couture

    Ermmm wow!!! Literally making my mouth water!! I know it’s a totally naughty dish but at least you have the whole rest of the day to work it off, right? :)

    • Cait

      Exactly! ;)

  • James

    You Make Foo So Beautiful Cait


    • James

      *Food, Lol

      • Cait

        Haha I knew what you meant – thank you!